ISSN 2415-3060 (print), ISSN 2522-4972 (online)
  • 44 of 61
Up
УЖМБС 2018, 3(5): 231–236
https://doi.org/10.26693/jmbs03.05.231
Medicine. Reviews

The Variability of the Validity of the Early Death Prescription

Konoval N. S.
Abstract

The article shows the direction of modern searches for a set of precise research methods that will overcome the variability of the criterion of the official methods of calculating the death prescription in the early postmortem period. The criterion for studying the death prescription in the early period is variable, and therefore the urgency of its resolution is obvious. There is a need to develop a modern, inexpensive, but informative and precise set of methods for determining the death prescription in the early postmortem period. The study offers the newest direction of defining death prescription criteria by means of complex research of different kinds of a muscular fabric of the person in the early postmortem period. The analysis of literary sources shows a number of shortcomings inherent in the traditional classical methods of determining the DNS, because they are based on the study of a large number of corpse’s heterogeneous objects, and therefore the methods lack the accuracy and repeatability. A number of new methods of calculating the DS, on the contrary, suffer from a small number of corpses’ bodies, and therefore they lack the credibility and objectivity of research. A breakthrough in defining DNS by high-tech effective methods has occurred recently. The accuracy of this method is significantly higher than the others. The international team of researchers led by Roderic Guigó of the Genome Regulatory Center discovered that the genes remained active for several days after human death. That is why changes in gene expression caused by death can be used to determine the most accurate DS factor in comparison with today's possibilities of forensic medical examination. We are adherents of the proposal of B. Mikhailichenko (2017) regarding the promising research of tissues having several species and spread throughout the body. Therefore, we choose for our own research muscle tissue, which has several species, occurs in almost all organs, vessels and tissues, and actively reacts to all changes of external and internal factors. Prospects of the proposed developments will be new, cheap and simple. These modern technological solutions for determining the death prescription with the help of accurate criteria in the early postmortem period will ensure the reliability, accuracy, objectivity, efficiency and repeatability of forensic research to resolve the law enforcement issues on the death prescription.

Keywords: prescription of death, criteria, complex of methods, muscles

Full text: PDF (Ukr) 208K

References
  1. Bachynskyy VT, ta in. Vyznachennya davnosti nastannya smerti pry deyakykh vydakh mekhanichnoyi asfiksiyi ta masyvniy krovovtrati metodamy lazernoyi polyarymetriyi. Monografiya. Chernivtsi, 2016. 146 s. [Ukrainian]
  2. Bylkun VV. K voprosu o tanatometrycheskom napravlenyy. Voprosy teoryy y praktyky sudebno-medytsynskoy ekspertyzy: sbornyk nauchnykh statey. Zaporozhe, 1995. s. 73-4. [Russian]
  3. Bylkun VV, Golubovych LL , Lakatosh VP. Nekotorye osobennosty yssledovanyya davnosty protsessov v sluchayakh massyvnykh travm. Ekspertnye kryteryy mekhanyzma povrezhdenyy y dyagnostyka davnosty ykh prychynenyya: respublykanskyy sb. nauchnykh trudov. Pod red VN Kryukova. Moskva, 2-y MOLGMY ym NY Pyrogova, 1984. s. 144-6. [Russian]
  4. Bokaryus NS. Pervonachalnyy osmotr trupa. Kharkov, 1925. 541 s. [Russian]
  5. Botezatu GA. Sudebno-medytsynskaya dyagnostyka davnosty nastuplenyya smerty. Kyshynev-Shtyyntsa, 1975. 131 s. [Russian]
  6. Buromskyy YV. Velychyna optycheskoy plotnosty nukleynovykh kyslot y produktov ykh raspada kak odyn yz pokazateley davnosty nastuplenyya smerty. Sudebno-medytsyskaya ekspertyza. 1980; 2: 15-6. [Russian]
  7. Vanchulyak OYa. Diagnostyka davnosti nastannya smerti metodom lazernogo polyarymetrychnogo monitoryngu tkanyn lyudyny: Abstr. PhDr. (Med.). Kyyiv, 2007. 20 s. [Ukrainian]
  8. Vyznachennya davnosti nastannya smerti. Monografiya. Za zag red VO Olkhovskogo, LL Golubovycha. Kharkiv: FOP Brovin O.V., 2017. 168 s. [Ukrainian]
  9. Vyznachennya davnosti nastannya smerti u sudovo-medychniy ekspertyzi. Metodychni vkazivky. Ukladachi: Mishalov VD, Mykhaylychenko BV, ta in. Kyyiv, 2014. 47 s. [Ukrainian]
  10. Dunayev OV. Vplyv alkogolyu na imunni pokaznyky trupnoyi krovi zagyblykh vid travm pry vstanovlenni davnosti nastannya smerti: Abstr. PhDr. (Med.). Kyyiv, 2004. 20 s. [Ukrainian]
  11. Kononenko VY. Kompleksnoe fyzyko-khymycheskoe yssledovanye trupnykh pyaten: Abstr. Dr. Sci. (Med.). K, 1971. 32 s. [Russian]
  12. Kononenko VY. Sudebno-medytsynskaya otsenka trupnykh pyaten (dyagnostycheskye tablytsy). Kharkov: KhYUV, 1993. 28 s. [Russian]
  13. Naydeny bezoshybochno opredelyayushchye vremya smerty mykrobnye chasy [digital resource]. Available from: https://lenta.ru/news/2015/12/11/necrobiome/ (Zagolovok z ekranu 29.03.2018 19:30) [Russian]
  14. Paymakova M. Novyy metod pozvolyt opredelyt tochnoe vremya smerty dazhe spustya 10 dney [digital resource]. Available from: https://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=2637022&cid=2161 (Zagolovok z ekranu 29.03.2018 r. 19:13) [Russian]
  15. Olkhovskyy VO, Golubovych LL, Khyzhnyak VV, Konoval NS, Dmytrenko YuO. Vyznachennya tryvalosti posmertnogo periodu v sudovo-medychniy ekspertniy praktytsi: suchasnyy stan ta perspektyvy. Eksperymentalna i klinichna medytsyna. 2016; 4: 154-62. [Ukrainian]
  16. Posmertnuyu uchast brennoy obolochky yzuchayut na fermakh tel [digital resource]. Available from: https://lenta.ru/articles/2014/11/14/bodyfarm/ (Zagolovok z ekranu 29.03.2018 r. 19:36) [Russian]
  17. Nakaz MOZ Ukrayiny № 6 vid 17.01.1995 r. Pro rozvytok ta vdoskonalennya sudovo-medychnoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny [digital resource]. Available from: http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0248-95 (09.04.2018 r. 17:35) [Ukrainian]
  18. Tagaev NN, Khyzhnyak VV, Kostylev DV, Morgun EA. Sudebno-medytsynskaya otsenka trupnykh yzmenenyy dlya opredelenyya vremeny y davnosty smerty. Praktycheskoe y uchebno-metodycheskoe posobye. Kharkov: SPDFL Brovyn A.V., 2011. 100 s. [Russian]
  19. Tenkov AA. Oshybky sudebno-medytsynskykh ekspertov y puty ykh predotvrashchenyya: praktycheskoe rukovodstvo. T 2. Kursk: KGMU, 2013. 556 s. [Russian]
  20. Vorobeva Yu. Tochnoe vremya smerty cheloveka mozhno opredelyt po yzmenenyyu aktyvnosty genov [digital resource]. Available from: https://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=2987976&tid=107617 (Zagolovok z ekranu 29.03.2018 r. 19:12) [Russian]